At a Glance
Rating Breakdown
Performance Overview
Scores out of 5, based on our editorial analysis
About Nationwide
Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company, founded in 1926 as the Farm Bureau Mutual Automobile Insurance Company in Columbus, Ohio, is a Fortune 100 financial services company with $53.4 billion in total assets and over 4.4 million policyholders. As a mutual company owned by its members rather than public shareholders, Nationwide operates with a structural advantage similar to State Farm and USAA: it can prioritize long-term member value over quarterly earnings. However, unlike State Farm (which dominates auto insurance) or USAA (which dominates military-market satisfaction), Nationwide's competitive identity has historically been harder to define. The company does a lot of things adequately — auto, home, life, pet, business, farm — but does not clearly dominate any single product line. This breadth-over-depth strategy creates genuine value for consumers who want to consolidate all insurance products under one carrier and one agent, but it also means that in any individual product category, a specialist competitor typically offers a better product at a comparable or lower price. Where Nationwide differentiates is homeowners insurance. The company's standard homeowners policy includes features that most competitors charge extra for or do not offer at all. Guaranteed replacement cost means Nationwide will pay to rebuild your home even if the cost exceeds your coverage limit — in the case study below, a total-loss fire in Ohio cost $385,000 to rebuild despite a $315,000 policy limit, and Nationwide covered the full amount. Built-in water backup coverage (typically a $50-$100/year endorsement at other carriers) protects against sewer and drain backup damage. Brand-name appliance replacement means that when a covered loss destroys your Kitchen Aid mixer or Bosch dishwasher, Nationwide replaces it with the same brand, not a cheap generic equivalent. These inclusions make Nationwide's homeowners premium appear 5-10% higher than Allstate's or Progressive's at first glance, but the built-in features eliminate the cost of add-on endorsements that other carriers require separately. For homeowners in catastrophe-prone areas (tornado alley, wildfire zones, flood plains), Nationwide's all-inclusive approach typically delivers better total value than a stripped-down competitor plus a la carte endorsements. Nationwide also operates the oldest and one of the largest pet insurance divisions in the United States, having offered pet insurance since 1982 — decades before Trupanion, Embrace, or Spot existed. The Nationwide pet program covers over 1 million pets and is the only major pet insurer that offers coverage for exotic animals (birds, reptiles, small mammals) in addition to dogs and cats. On the auto side, Nationwide's SmartRide telematics program offers discounts up to 40% based on driving behavior, competitive with Progressive's Snapshot and Allstate's Drivewise. However, Nationwide's J.D. Power satisfaction scores in auto (3.8) consistently rank below the industry average, which is the primary reason we do not recommend Nationwide as a standalone auto insurer. The company is best suited for consumers who want a homeowners-first strategy with bundled auto, life, and pet coverage from a single mutual carrier, accepting slightly below-average auto insurance service quality in exchange for thorough homeowners coverage and multi-policy discounts.
Key Features
Superior Homeowners Coverage
Nationwide's homeowners policies include brand-name appliance replacement, built-in water backup coverage, and guaranteed replacement cost that exceeds your coverage limit if rebuild costs increase.
On Your Side Review
Annual complimentary review with your agent to ensure your coverage keeps pace with life changes, home improvements, and evolving needs.
SmartRide Telematics
Nationwide's usage-based program monitors driving through an app or OBD-II device and offers up to 40% in safe-driving discounts.
How It Works
Get a Quote
Request a quote online, by phone, or through one of Nationwide's exclusive or independent agents.
Customize Your Coverage
Select coverage levels, deductibles, and endorsements. Your agent helps identify bundling and discount opportunities.
Bundle & Save
Combine auto, home, life, or pet coverage for multi-policy discounts of up to 20%.
Manage Your Policies
Use the Nationwide app or online portal for payments, claims, documents, and the annual On Your Side Review.
What They Do
- Homeowners Insurance
- Auto Insurance
- Life Insurance
- Pet Insurance
- Renters Insurance
- Condo Insurance
- Business Insurance
- Farm Insurance
Debt Types They Take On
- Homeowners
- Auto
- Life
- Pet
- Renters
- Condo
- Business
- Farm
- Umbrella
Fee & Cost Structure
Regulatory & Trust
Review Summary
Notable Case Studies
Guaranteed Replacement Cost Covering a $70,000 Shortfall
Homeowner in Dayton, OH, experienced a total-loss fire in February 2024 that destroyed a 2,400 sq ft colonial home insured for $315,000. Post-disaster construction inflation (lumber prices, contractor demand in the region after multiple winter storms) pushed the actual rebuild cost to $385,000 — 22% above the policy limit.
Multi-Line Bundling with Pet Insurance
Family in Columbus, OH, with a home, two cars, a $500K term life policy, and two dogs (Golden Retriever and Beagle) was paying $8,200/year across four separate carriers: Erie for home, Progressive for auto, Haven Life for term, and Embrace for pet insurance.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Best-in-market homeowners coverage with guaranteed replacement cost, water backup, and brand-name appliance replacement included in the standard policy — features that competitors either charge extra for or skip entirely, which matters most for homeowners in catastrophe-prone areas
- Annual On Your Side Review with your agent ensures coverage keeps pace with home improvements, life changes, and evolving needs — a proactive service that most carriers do not offer, frequently identifying coverage gaps before they become problems
- Broadest product range of any single carrier reviewed on this page — auto, home, life, pet, business, farm, renters, condo, and umbrella — making Nationwide the best option for consumers who want all insurance products under one roof with one agent
- Mutual company structure with $53.4 billion in assets and AM Best A+ rating provides strong financial stability without the shareholder pressure that publicly traded competitors face — member-owned governance prioritizes long-term policyholder value
- Oldest and one of the largest pet insurance programs in the United States (since 1982) with unique coverage for exotic animals (birds, reptiles, small mammals) that no other major pet insurer offers at scale
Cons
- Auto insurance premiums average 8-15% above direct writers like GEICO and Progressive for comparable coverage, reflecting the cost of Nationwide's agent-based distribution model — consumers who prioritize the cheapest auto premium will find better rates elsewhere
- J.D. Power auto insurance satisfaction scores of 3.8 are consistently below the industry average and significantly below leaders like USAA (4.9), State Farm (4.5), and GEICO (4.4), indicating persistent customer service gaps in the auto claims process
- Homeowners claims process averages 14-21 days for complex claims, slower than digital-first competitors like Lemonade (3 minutes for AI-eligible claims) and slower than State Farm's agent-advocated process — the guaranteed replacement cost is excellent, but the speed to receive payment is not
- SmartRide telematics program, while offering up to 40% discounts, has lower adoption rates and less transparent data privacy policies than Progressive's Snapshot — Nationwide's telematics discounts average 10-15% in practice versus the advertised 40% maximum
User Reviews (10)
vanishing deductible reduced my auto deductible to $0
Nationwide's vanishing deductible program reduces your collision and comprehensive deductible by $100 for each claim-free year. Started with a $500 deductible. After 5 claim-free years, my deductible is $0. This is a truly unique feature -- most carriers fix your deductible for life. Getting a $0 deductible reward for being a safe driver makes the slightly higher base premium worth it. When I finally had a claim, paying nothing out of pocket felt amazing.
term life is competitively priced through their agent network
$500K 20-year term through Nationwide: $30/month at age 34. Haven Life was $26 and Ladder was $24. Nationwide is $4-6/month more expensive for term life. But my Nationwide agent bundled the life policy with my auto and home for an additional 3% discount across all lines. After the multi-policy discount, the net cost difference was only $2/month. If you already bundle with Nationwide, adding life insurance through them makes financial sense after discounts.
their commercial/business insurance is excellent
Run a small business. Nationwide's commercial insurance (BOP -- Business Owners Policy) was 20% cheaper than The Hartford and included cyber liability coverage that others charged extra for. The commercial lines division is where Nationwide really excels. For small business owners who want personal and commercial coverage from one carrier, Nationwide's commercial products are seriously competitive. This is their hidden strength.
solid all-around carrier, nothing spectacular
Been with Nationwide for auto and home for 5 years. Rates are middle of the pack -- not cheapest (GEICO wins), not most expensive (Allstate loses). Claims have been handled competently (2 auto claims, both resolved in 2-3 weeks). Agent is responsive but not as involved as my friend's State Farm agent. Nationwide is the Honda Civic of insurance -- reliable, functional, unremarkable. If you want the cheapest rate, look elsewhere. If you want stability, Nationwide is fine.
one of the few carriers still accessible in rural areas
Live in rural Ohio. GEICO has no physical presence. Progressive's nearest agent is 40 miles away. Nationwide has a local agent in my town of 8,000 people. For rural and small-town America, Nationwide's agent network matters. When my barn was damaged in a storm, a local adjuster who understood agricultural properties came out. Not every carrier has adjusters who know the difference between a pole barn and a finished garage. Nationwide does because they started in Ohio farm country.
homeowners coverage is thorough with better-than-average endorsements
Nationwide's homeowners policy includes brand-name replacement, which means if my Samsung TV is destroyed, they replace it with a current Samsung TV, not a generic equivalent. Also includes $25K identity theft coverage at no extra cost. These endorsements are included in the base policy while competitors charge extra for them. For homeowners specifically, Nationwide's coverage quality is above average even if their pricing is middle of the road.
mobile app does the basics, nothing more
Nationwide's app handles policy viewing, ID cards, bill pay, and basic claim filing. No fancy features, no spending insights, no proactive recommendations. The app is about 3 years behind GEICO's and 5 years behind USAA's in terms of features and UX. For a company their size ($40B+ in premiums), the technology investment should be higher. I use the app for ID cards and payments. For anything complex, I call my agent. The app supplements but doesn't replace the agent relationship.
one of the only carriers offering pet insurance alongside auto/home
Nationwide is one of the few traditional insurers that also offers pet insurance. Bundled my dog's coverage with auto and home for a 5% discount on each line. The pet coverage itself is average -- $50/month for a 4-year-old Lab, $7,500 annual limit. Trupanion and Embrace are better dedicated pet insurers. But the convenience of having auto + home + pet with one company and one bill is appealing for simplicity-minded people.
the On Your Side Review was actually useful
My Nationwide agent does an annual "On Your Side Review" where they go through all my policies and look for gaps, discounts, or changes. Last year they caught that I was paying for roadside assistance through Nationwide AND AAA (duplicate coverage). Saved me $75/year by dropping AAA. The annual review isn't just a sales pitch -- it actually found savings I'd missed. Proactive policy reviews are something GEICO and Progressive will never offer because they don't have agents.
claims are handled but not quickly
Had a home claim for wind damage ($4,200). Filed the claim, adjuster came in 10 days (not fast), estimate approved in another week, check arrived in week 3. Total: 3 weeks. Not terrible but not impressive. State Farm and USAA handle similar claims in 7-10 days. Nationwide's claims department is adequate -- they pay what they owe and don't fight you, but they don't prioritize speed. For minor claims, the wait isn't a big deal. For major damage, 3 weeks feels long.
Write a Review
Frequently Asked Questions
Embed This Badge on Your Website
Nationwide has earned a Best for Homeowners designation from Zogby. Display this badge on your website to showcase your rating.
Paste this code anywhere in your website's HTML. The badge links back to your full Zogby review.
Related Companies
Important Insurance Disclaimers
- Insurance premiums, coverage limits, and deductibles vary based on your location, driving record, claims history, credit score, and other underwriting factors. The quotes and rates referenced on this page are for informational purposes only and do not constitute a guarantee of coverage or pricing.
- Not all insurance products are available in all states. Coverage options, policy terms, and eligibility requirements differ by state due to varying regulatory frameworks. Check with each insurer directly for availability in your area.
- Filing an insurance claim may affect your future premiums. Insurers may increase rates after claims, accidents, or changes in risk profile. Review your policy terms carefully before filing a claim.
- Insurance ratings and financial strength grades (AM Best, S&P, Moody's) reflect the insurer's ability to pay claims and are not a recommendation to purchase a specific policy. Past financial performance does not guarantee future stability.
- Zogby does not sell insurance policies or act as an insurance broker. We are an independent comparison service providing editorial reviews and general information. Always consult a licensed insurance agent or broker for personalized advice.
This page is informational, not financial or legal advice. Talk to a qualified professional before making any big money decisions.
Editorial Independence
We make money from some companies on this page. That doesn't change our rankings -- the editorial team scores every product independently, and the business side has no say in what we recommend.