At a Glance
Rating Breakdown
Performance Overview
Scores out of 5, based on our editorial analysis
About Autopay
Autopay, formerly known as RateGenius, was founded in 2007 in Austin, Texas (now headquartered in Denver) and has handled over $5 billion in auto loan refinancing through its marketplace model. Like Splash Financial for student loans, Autopay is not a lender. It operates as an intermediary that distributes your application to a network of banks, credit unions, and online auto lenders who compete for your business. Autopay earns referral fees from the lending partners, not from borrowers. The company rebranded from RateGenius to Autopay in 2022 to reflect an expanded product line that includes new car financing, used car financing, and lease buyout loans alongside its core refinancing product. The auto loan refinancing use case is compelling because dealership financing is systematically overpriced. Dealers earn profit through rate markup: the lender approves you at 5%, the dealer quotes 8%, and the 3% spread is split between the dealer and the lender as a kickback. This practice is legal and nearly universal, which means most buyers who financed through a dealership are paying 2-4% above the rate they could qualify for independently. Autopay's marketplace connects these over-charged borrowers with lenders willing to refinance at the lower rate. A single application generates 2-5 competing offers, and Autopay handles the entire payoff process with the existing lender including title transfer. Autopay's minimum credit score of 550 and APR range starting at 5.19% suggest a wide borrower base, but the best rates require 720+ scores and vehicles under 7 years old with fewer than 100,000 miles. Older vehicles, high-mileage cars, and subprime borrowers will see significantly fewer offers and higher rates. Cash-back refinancing is available for borrowers whose vehicle is worth more than their loan balance, essentially allowing you to borrow against vehicle equity for any purpose. However, this extends your loan term and increases total interest paid, so it should only be used when the alternative is a higher-rate form of credit like credit cards.
Key Features
Multi-Lender Marketplace
One application generates offers from a network of banks, credit unions, and online lenders.
Handles Payoff Process
Autopay manages the payoff of your existing loan directly with your current lender.
Cash-Back Refinancing
Eligible borrowers may receive cash back when refinancing a vehicle with significant equity.
How It Works
Check Your Rate
Submit a single application and receive competing offers from multiple lenders in minutes.
Compare Offers
Review side-by-side rate comparisons and estimated monthly savings from each lender.
Select Your Lender
Choose the offer that provides the best combination of rate, term, and monthly payment.
Autopay Handles the Rest
Autopay pays off your existing lender and transfers the title to the new loan.
What They Do
- Auto Loan Refinancing
- New Car Financing
- Used Car Financing
- Cash-Back Auto Refinance
- Lease Buyout Financing
Debt Types They Take On
- Existing Auto Loans
- High-Interest Dealer Financing
- Lease Buyout Debt
Fee & Cost Structure
Regulatory & Trust
Review Summary
Notable Case Studies
Dealership Markup Refinance
A buyer with a 690 FICO financed a 2023 Honda CR-V through the dealership at 11.4% APR over 72 months with a $28,500 balance. The dealer had marked up the rate from the bank's approved 6.9% by 4.5 percentage points. Monthly payment: $554. After 8 months of payments, the remaining balance was $26,800 and the borrower's credit score had improved to 710.
Cash-Back Refinance for Emergency Expenses
A borrower had a 2022 Toyota Tacoma with a loan balance of $24,000 at 8.2% APR. The truck was valued at $33,000 (KBB), providing $9,000 in equity. The borrower needed $5,000 for an emergency medical expense and was considering a personal loan at 18% APR or a credit card cash advance at 25.9%.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Marketplace model generates 2-5 competing offers from one application, introducing price competition that consistently beats the rate buyers originally received from dealership financing
- No platform fees to borrowers: Autopay earns from lender referral fees, so the service itself is free and the rates you see are the actual rates from lending partners
- Full payoff management means Autopay handles paying off your existing lender, managing the title transfer, and coordinating with the new lender, making the refinance process nearly hands-off
- Cash-back refinancing allows borrowers with vehicle equity to access cash at auto loan rates (5-10%) rather than personal loan rates (14-18%) or credit card rates (22-28%), providing a low-cost emergency funding source
- Minimum credit score of 550 and verified client reputation indicate both accessibility and operational reliability, with only 290 CFPB complaints over three years, which is exceptionally low for the company's volume
Cons
- As a marketplace, the final lending experience depends entirely on the partner you select. Customer service quality, payment portal usability, and issue resolution vary by lender and Autopay cannot intervene after funding
- Older vehicles (8+ years) and high-mileage cars (100,000+ miles) receive significantly fewer offers or no offers at all, as many lenders restrict refinancing to newer vehicles with sufficient remaining useful life
- Some lending partners impose minimum loan balance requirements ($7,500-$10,000), which means borrowers close to paying off their existing loan may not qualify for refinancing even if the rate savings are substantial
- Cash-back refinancing extends your loan term and increases total interest paid, which can lead to being underwater (owing more than the car is worth) if the vehicle depreciates faster than expected
User Reviews (12)
active duty -- one of their CU partners offered me 3.9%
Active duty Army. One of Autopay's credit union partners (PenFed) offered me 3.9% APR for my auto refi. Military-specific rates that I wouldn't have found without the marketplace. Refinanced $26K from 7.1% dealer rate to 3.9%. Monthly savings of $76. If you're military or a veteran, definitely check Autopay -- their marketplace includes military-focused credit unions with rates that civilian lenders can't match.
used Autopay to finance my lease buyout
My lease was ending and I wanted to buy the car. The dealer quoted 7.9% APR for the buyout financing. Used Autopay's marketplace and got 5.2% from a credit union. Saved about $2,400 over a 60-month term vs the dealer rate. Not all refi/lending platforms handle lease buyouts but Autopay does. If your lease is ending and you want to keep the car, check Autopay before accepting the dealer's buyout financing rate.
they refinanced my 95K mile car which many won't
Most auto refi lenders cap at 75K-100K miles. My 2020 Subaru Outback had 95K miles. Three lenders through Autopay declined me on mileage alone. One accepted at 6.9% which was still better than my original 9.5%. Autopay's marketplace approach meant I could find the ONE lender willing to work with high-mileage vehicles. If you have a high-mileage car, the marketplace model increases your odds of finding an accepting lender vs applying individually.
my 2016 car was too old for most of their lenders
2016 Honda Civic with 78K miles. Most lenders in Autopay's marketplace won't refinance cars older than 7 model years. Only got one offer and it was barely better than my current rate (7.2% vs 7.8%). For newer cars (2020+) the marketplace has great options. For older cars, you might be better off going directly to a credit union that specifically handles older vehicle refinancing. Autopay's partner lenders skew toward newer vehicles.
refinanced my auto loan, way cheaper now
Dealership got me at 11.1% APR on a $28K auto loan because I was so focused on the monthly payment I forgot to negotiate the rate. Classic mistake. Found Autopay through a reddit thread on r/personalfinance. Refinanced to 5.9% which dropped my payment from $640 to $498. Saving $142/month and about $5,100 over the remaining loan term. The application took 10 minutes and they handled the payoff to my old lender. This is the easiest money I've ever saved.
service is fine but they're mostly a matchmaker
Autopay connects you with lenders but once you accept an offer, the customer service relationship is with the LENDER, not Autopay. When I had a question about my payment schedule, Autopay told me to call the credit union directly. They're a matchmaker not a servicer. This is fine if you understand it upfront but confusing if you expect Autopay to manage your ongoing loan relationship. They find you the deal, then step back.
old loan paid off in 3 business days
Applied Tuesday. Approved Wednesday. Old lender paid off by Friday. New lower payment started the following month. Total elapsed time: 3 business days. The speed was impressive because auto refinancing usually takes 1-2 weeks with all the payoff coordination. Autopay handles the entire payoff process -- they send the check to your old lender, get the title transferred, and update the lien. I didn't have to do anything except sign and wait.
heads up: refinancing cancels your dealer GAP insurance
Something nobody told me until after I refinanced: my dealer-purchased GAP insurance was tied to the original loan. When Autopay paid off that loan, the GAP coverage was automatically cancelled. I was entitled to a pro-rated refund (got about $380 back) but had to buy new GAP coverage through my new lender. Not Autopay's fault but it's something to be aware of. Check whether you have GAP insurance before refinancing and plan for the coverage transition.
showed me offers from multiple lenders at once
Autopay is a marketplace, not a direct lender. They showed me refinance offers from 4 different credit unions and banks. Rates ranged from 5.4% to 7.8% for my $22K remaining balance. I picked the best one (5.4% from a credit union I'd never heard of) and Autopay managed the entire process. Having multiple competing offers in one place is exactly how auto lending should work. Only complaint: the follow-up calls were aggressive. 3 calls the first day.
completely free service -- lenders pay them not you
Zero cost to the borrower. Autopay gets paid by the lenders for the referral. I paid no application fee, no origination fee, no processing fee. The refinance itself had no hidden costs. Went from 8.8% to 5.5% on $18K remaining. Monthly savings of $58 which adds up to about $1,740 over the remaining term. A free service that saves you money with zero downside. The only cost is answering their follow-up calls lol.
Write a Review
Frequently Asked Questions
Embed This Badge on Your Website
Autopay has earned a Best Auto Loan Refinance designation from Zogby. Display this badge on your website to showcase your rating.
Paste this code anywhere in your website's HTML. The badge links back to your full Zogby review.
Related Companies
Important Auto Loan Disclaimers
- Annual Percentage Rates (APRs), loan amounts, and terms displayed are estimates based on publicly available information and may vary based on your creditworthiness, income, and other factors. Actual rates, terms, and availability may differ from what is shown here.
- Checking your rate or pre-qualifying with a lender typically involves a soft credit inquiry that does not affect your credit score. However, submitting a formal application will result in a hard credit inquiry, which may temporarily lower your score.
- Origination fees, late fees, prepayment penalties, and other charges vary by lender. Review all loan terms, fees, and conditions in the loan agreement before signing.
- Personal loans are not suitable for all financial situations. Failure to repay a personal loan can result in collection activity, negative credit reporting, lawsuits, and wage garnishment. Consider your ability to repay before borrowing.
- Zogby does not originate, fund, or service loans. We are an independent comparison service and do not make lending decisions or guarantee approval for any product.
This page is informational, not financial or legal advice. Talk to a qualified professional before making any big money decisions.
Editorial Independence
We make money from some companies on this page. That doesn't change our rankings -- the editorial team scores every product independently, and the business side has no say in what we recommend.