Which Hemorrhoid Treatment Is Better: Tucks or Preparation H?
Hemorrhoids can cause discomfort and pain in the anal area. If you’re experiencing such symptoms, you need relief as soon as possible. Two over-the-counter products popularly used to treat hemorrhoids are Tucks and Preparation H.
What Are Tucks?
Tucks is a brand of medicated pads made by Johnson & Johnson. The pads contain witch hazel, which has astringent properties that can reduce inflammation and irritation in the anal area. They also contain other soothing ingredients such as glycerin and alcohol.
What Is Preparation H?
Preparation H is a brand of creams, ointments, and suppositories owned by Pfizer. Its active ingredient is phenylephrine, a decongestant that can shrink swollen blood vessels. The product also contains mineral oil and petrolatum that forms a protective barrier on the skin, reducing itching and pain.
How Do They Compare?
Both Tucks and Preparation H are effective in treating hemorrhoids. However, they have different mechanisms of action and provide different benefits.
Tucks vs Preparation H: Mechanism of Action
| Tucks | Preparation H | |
|---|---|---|
| Main Ingredients | Witch Hazel, Glycerin, Alcohol | Phenylephrine, Mineral Oil, Petrolatum |
| Actions | Astringent properties that reduce inflammation and irritation. Soothes and cleanses | Decongestant, shrinks swollen blood vessels. Forms a protective barrier on the skin. |
Tucks: The main ingredient in Tucks is witch hazel, which is known for its astringent properties. It helps reduce swelling, inflammation, and irritation. The glycerin and alcohol in Tucks also provide a cooling effect, reducing discomfort and pain.
Preparation H: The active ingredient in Preparation H is phenylephrine, which constricts blood vessels and reduces blood flow to the affected area. This leads to less swelling and less pressure, easing discomfort. Petrolatum and mineral oil form a protective barrier that soothes dry, itchy skin.
Tucks vs Preparation H: Formulation
| Tucks | Preparation H | |
|---|---|---|
| Pads | Yes | No |
| Creams | No | Yes |
| Ointments | No | Yes |
| Suppositories | No | Yes |
Tucks: Tucks are medicated pads that can be used for gentle cleansing of the anal area. They come in a container that keeps them moist, making them convenient and easy to use.
Preparation H: This brand is available in creams, ointments, and suppositories with varying formulations suitable for daytime or nighttime use. Each form has specific directions and instructions on how to use it.
Tucks vs Preparation H: Cost
| Tucks | Preparation H | |
|---|---|---|
| Price Range | $4-$10 | $6-$20 |
| Amount per Container | 40-100 pads | 0.9-2.0 oz ointment; 12 suppositories |
Tucks: Tucks are cheaper than Preparation H, with prices ranging from $4 to $10 for 100 pads. One pad can be used multiple times, meaning you could use up to 100 times per container.
Preparation H: Its prices range between $6 and $20 depending on the type of product and size of the container. For example, a 2oz tube of cream could last up to a few weeks—with proper usage—while a 12-count suppositories box could only last for a few days.
Which One Should You Choose?
The choice between Tucks and Preparation H depends on personal preference, budget, and the severity of your symptoms.
If you’re looking for an effortless way to soothe the discomfort and irritation associated with hemorrhoids, medicated pads like Tucks could be the right choice for you. If you’re searching for a more intensive formulation that targets swelling, a cream or suppository like Preparation H may be better.
Ultimately, both products are effective in treating hemorrhoids. Consult your doctor if your symptoms do not improve after using over-the-counter treatments.
Get it on 
Download on the